The IRS tax gap is a persistent concern that is central to how the Service sets priorities, so it's important for tax professionals to be aware of this issue. In practical terms, the tax gap shapes where enforcement resources go and which returns are most likely to draw scrutiny. To ensure your clients' compliance and documentation practices don't lead to any IRS red flags, we're sharing what the tax gap is, how the IRS calculates tax gap estimates, tax gap limitations and implications of the data.
What Is the IRS Tax Gap?
The tax gap is the difference between true tax liability for a given period and the amount of tax that is actually paid both voluntarily and on time. For measurement purposes, the IRS distinguishes between the gross tax gap and the net tax gap and also breaks the tax gap into three behavioral components: nonfiling, underreporting, and underpayment.
Gross Tax Gap vs Net Tax Gap
- Gross tax gap: The initial shortfall in a given period, such as outstanding payments
- Net tax gap: The shortfall remaining after late payments and enforcement collections, such as audits and collection actions
The Behavioral Components of the Tax Gap
- Nonfiling: Required returns that are never filed
- Underreporting: Returns are filed, but income is understated or deductions/credits are overstated (Note: this component factors the most to the tax gap)
- Underpayment: Returns are substantively accurate, but taxpayers do not pay the full amount by the due date
In addition to the dollar amounts, the IRS tracks a voluntary compliance rate (VCR) and a a net compliance rate (NCR). These rates represent the share of “true” tax liability that gets paid on time (VCR) and ultimately after enforcement and late payments (NCR). For long‑term trends, these rates can matter more than the exact dollar figures, because they show whether taxpayer behavior is improving, deteriorating, or holding steady.
Visit Becker's Tax Resource Center
Keep up with the latest tax legislation, build your skills, or maintain your credentials with CPE or IRS-approved CE!
How Much Is the Estimated Tax Gap?
The IRS estimates the tax gap periodically to help the agency analyze trends and best determine how to allocate its resources. The estimates consider federal taxes due and factor in refundable and nonrefundable credits. Recent IRS research puts the tax gap in the hundreds of billions of dollars per year on a gross basis, even after accounting for late payments and enforcement. While specific estimates vary by tax year and are often updated as methods improve, trends show that the gross tax gap has grown over time as the economy and total tax liability have grown.
At the same time, overall compliance rates have tended to be relatively stable, generally around 85% on a voluntary basis and somewhat higher after enforcement and late payments are included. That suggests the tax gap is a structural feature of the system rather than the result of a sudden behavioral shift in any single year. It also underscores the reality that closing the gap completely is not feasible. Instead, policymakers and the IRS focus on making incremental improvements where they are most cost‑effective.
It's also important for tax practitioners to consider timing. Official tax gap estimates are produced with a lag because they rely on detailed audit studies and modeling. More recent years may initially appear only as projections, and earlier years can be revised when new data or improved methods become available.
Prior Year Tax Gaps
- 2011–2013: $438 billion
- 2014–2016: $496 billion
- 2017–2019: Projected at $540 billion with the tax gap of the three components estimated at:
- Nonfiling: $41 billion
- Underreporting: $433 billion
- Underpayment: $66 billion
Where Does the Tax Gap Come From?
The tax gap comes from two areas—the behavioral components (nonfiling, underreporting, and underpayment) and the types of tax.
Behavioral Components
Underreporting
Underreporting is the largest single component and is most prevalent in areas where there is limited or no third‑party information reporting and withholding. Classic examples include cash‑intensive businesses, sole proprietorships, certain rental activities, and some forms of gig and platform work that historically have been under‑reported or loosely documented. The absence of robust third‑party reporting in these areas makes it easier for income to be understated or deductions and credits to be stretched.
Nonfiling
Nonfiling reflects taxpayers who are required to file but do not submit a return at all. This can involve people transitioning into self‑employment, individuals with multiple income sources who lose track of filing obligations, and those experiencing life events like job loss or health crises. In practice, nonfilers often surface when they need a transcript or return for a lender, immigration process, or other purpose, giving practitioners an opportunity to address multiple open years at once.
Underpayment
Underpayment involves taxpayers who file accurate or nearly accurate returns but fail to pay the full amount due by the deadline. This often ties back to cash‑flow constraints, poor estimated tax planning, or optimistic assumptions about the ability to “catch up” later. For professionals, it’s an area where proactive planning can meaningfully reduce penalties and interest for clients.
Type of Tax
From a tax‑type perspective, the individual income tax drives most of the tax gap. This reflects both the size of the individual income tax base and the wide range of income types and deductions that flow through individual returns, particularly from pass‑through entities and sole proprietorships.
Employment and self‑employment taxes make up another substantial portion, especially where worker classification, cash wages, and small‑business payroll practices are involved. Corporate income tax and other categories (such as estate or excise taxes) contribute as well, but they are not the primary drivers in aggregate. This breakdown helps explain why recent enforcement rhetoric and planning have emphasized high‑income individuals, pass‑through entities, and complex business structures rather than only large C‑corporations.
Caveats of the Estimated IRS Tax Gap
According to the IRS, given the complexity of the tax system and available data, no single approach can be used for estimating each component of the tax gap and each approach is subject to measurement or nonsampling error. The IRS has provided several factors to keep in mind:
- The IRS lacks data related to offshore accounts, digital assets, corporate income tax, income from pass-through entities, and illegal activities, so the estimates cannot fully represent noncompliance related to those factors.
- The tax gap associated with illegal activities has been outside the scope of tax gap estimation because the objective of government is to eliminate those activities, which would eliminate any associated tax.
- For noncompliance associated with digital assets and other emerging issues, it takes time to develop the expertise to uncover associated noncompliance and for examinations to be completed that can be used to measure the extent of that noncompliance.
Policy and Enforcement of the IRS Tax Gap
In recent years, the tax gap has featured prominently in debates about IRS funding, modernization, and enforcement strategy. The IRS has been moving steadily toward more data‑driven enforcement, including using enhanced analytics and expanded information reporting to better identify returns that deviate from expected patterns given a taxpayer’s profile, industry, and third‑party reports. Rather than uniformly increasing traditional full‑scope audits, the IRS is using more issue‑focused exams, correspondence contacts, and automated notices that challenge specific items or request additional documentation.
For practitioners, this means more targeted interactions with notices that zero in on particular lines and campaigns focused on specific transaction types or industries. There can also be an expectation that returns with complex flows of income and low information reporting will receive more scrutiny.
What Does Tax Gap Enforcement Mean for Tax Professionals?
The tax gap is not just an abstract fiscal statistic; it is effectively a map of where your clients are most exposed. Areas that contribute heavily to the gap include:
- Schedule C income
- Pass‑through allocations
- Cash‑intensive operations
- Refundable credits
- Basis and loss rules
Thus, these are also areas where you can expect greater attention, whether through automated matching programs or human examiners. From a risk‑management standpoint, tax professionals can respond in several ways:
- Strengthen intake and engagement processes to flag high‑risk items early, including undocumented income streams, aggressive deductions, and prior nonfiling
- Raise the bar on documentation and workpaper quality in known risk areas, ensuring that positions are well supported and that contemporaneous records exist
- Revisit due‑diligence procedures, especially around credits and self‑employment income, to align with current standards and enforcement focus
At the same time, the tax gap creates advisory opportunities. Helping clients establish better recordkeeping systems, internal controls, and processes can both improve compliance and add tangible business value. Thoughtful estimated tax planning and cash‑flow management can reduce the underpayment component that often leads to penalties and client frustration. For clients with historical issues, such as unfiled years, chronic underreporting, or lingering balances, professionals can guide them through remediation strategies, from delinquent filings to installment agreements and other resolution options. A practical way to operationalize this is to identify the top tax‑gap‑sensitive segments in your own client base—sole proprietors, small pass‑throughs, or high‑income individuals with multiple schedule k-1 1065s —then align your procedures, training, and monitoring around those engagements.
Expand Your Tax Knowledge with Becker
With over 100 IRS-approved continuing education courses in tax, ethics, and other key topics, Becker makes it easy for you to keep up with tax legislation, tax trends, and even the compliance needs of your credential. Visit our tax resource center to get started!
Learn More about the EA Credential
Related Articles
Share
