Selecting the appropriate business structure is a crucial decision for entrepreneurs. While you (or your clients) may be more concerned about choosing a business name, choosing the right business entity can have far-reaching implications for your company's financial health and legal protection. Two of the most popular options for small businesses are S Corporations (S Corps) and Limited Liability Companies (LLCs). This article will help you understand the key differences between S Corps vs LLCs as making an informed choice can optimize your tax situation and safeguard your personal assets.
Table of contents
What is an S Corp?
S Corporations elect to pass corporate income, losses, deductions, and credits to their shareholders for federal tax purposes while offering liability protection. Shareholders of S corps report the flow-through of income and losses on their personal tax returns and are assessed tax at their individual income tax rates.
Additionally, shareholders may qualify for the Section 199A deduction, allowing them to deduct up to 20% of their Qualified Business Income (QBI). However, wages paid to shareholder-employees are excluded from this deduction. This structure allows S Corporations to avoid double taxation on corporate income.
S Corporations that were previously C Corporations are responsible for tax on built-in gains and passive income at the entity level from the sale of certain assets owned at the time of conversion to S Corporation status.
What is an LLC?
An LLC, or Limited Liability Company, combines the characteristics of a corporation with those of a partnership or sole proprietorship, protecting owners from personal liability for business debt and liabilities while offering greater flexibility and tax advantages. That's the simple definition, but let's dig a little deeper.
An LLC is a state-recognized business entity. The owners of an LLC, known as members, can include individuals, corporations, other LLCs, and even foreign entities, with no limits on membership. This flexibility allows for unlimited members, making it an appealing option for entrepreneurs, but LLCs can also be formed as "single-member" entities, meaning just one individual can own them.
Depending on the LLC's elections and the number of members, the IRS may classify the LLC as a corporation, a partnership, or a disregarded entity, which is reported on the owner's tax return. In addition, LLC members may qualify for the Section 199A deduction, which allows them to deduct up to 20% of their Qualified Business Income (QBI). This deduction applies to LLCs treated as disregarded entities, partnerships, or S corporations but does not apply to LLCs electing C corporation treatment. Overall, LLCs offer significant flexibility in their structure and tax classification, making them appealing to a wide range of business owners.
S Corp vs LLC: Eligibility requirements and formation
S Corp: Formation and eligibility requirements
When weighing an S Corp vs LLC, let's look at the eligibility requirements. To become an S Corporation, a business must meet these criteria:
- Incorporated in the US: Shareholders are limited to individuals, specific types of trusts, and estates. Partnerships, corporations, or nonresidents are not allowed.
- Have no more than 100 shareholders
- Have only one class of stock
- Be an eligible corporation
Formation process
- Choose a name for the business
- Prepare and file Articles of Incorporation with the Secretary of State File required state business licenses, permits, and annual reports
- Apply for EIN from the IRS using Form SS-4
- Submit S Corporation election (Form 2553) within 2.5 months of the start of the tax year
- Issue stock to the shareholders in exchange for their contributions
- Hold the first board meeting to appoint officers and adopt bylaws
- Keep minutes of this and all subsequent meetings
LLC: Formation and eligibility requirements
Before proceeding with the formation process, it is essential to understand who can form a Limited Liability Company (LLC) and under what conditions. When considering an S Corp vs LLC, remember that state law sets the requirements for forming an LLC, so you'll want to check with your state's specific rules and guidelines.
To be recognized as a legal entity, an LLC should have at least one member, and there is no limit to the number of members an LLC can have. Members can include individuals, C-corporations, other LLCs, trusts, retirement accounts, and foreign entities. Most states permit single-member LLCs, which have only one member.
Formation process
- Select a unique business name
- Apply for employer identification number (if required)
- Designate a registered agent
- File Articles of Organization with the Secretary of State
- Draft an operating agreement
- File required state business licenses, permits, and annual reports
- Make tax elections
S Corp vs LLCs: Weighing the pros and cons
S Corp Pros and Cons
Pro #1: Pass-through taxation
S Corporations offer significant tax advantages that can significantly impact a business's bottom line. One of the main benefits is pass-through taxation, where business income is reported directly on shareholders' tax returns. This structure enables shareholders to report their profits and losses on their returns, avoiding the double taxation that C corporations face.
Pro #2: Liability protection
The S Corporation structure provides flexibility in handling business losses. Subject to certain limitations, shareholders can pass operating losses, which are often encountered during the early stages of a business, through to their tax returns to offset other income. Furthermore, S corporations offer limited liability protection comparable to C corporations, safeguarding shareholders' personal assets from business debts while benefiting from favorable tax treatment.
Pro #3: Reduced self-employment tax
When weighing between S Corp vs LLC, one of the biggest factors to consider is the self-employment tax. Self-employment tax reduction represents another significant advantage of the S corporation structure. Unlike sole proprietors, who must pay the full 15.3% self-employment tax on all business income, S corporation shareholders can strategically reduce this burden through compensation planning. Shareholders must pay themselves a reasonable salary, which is subject to payroll taxes (Social Security and Medicare). However, any additional company profits distributed to shareholders are not subject to self-employment taxes, allowing them to save on overall tax obligations.
Disadvantage #1: Restrictions and less flexibility
While the tax benefits are substantial, S Corporations face certain restrictions and additional costs. The business must meet specific eligibility requirements, including having no more than 100 shareholders (US citizens or residents), who must be individuals, certain trusts, estates, or tax-exempt organizations. The corporation must be domestic, have only one class of stock, and cannot be a certain type of financial institution or insurance company.
Disadvantage #2: State taxes
Some states impose their taxes on S Corporations so when deciding between S Corp vs LLC, it's important to check state-specific guidelines.
LLC Pros and Cons
Pro#1: Liability protection
Limited liability protection, protecting the owner's personal assets from liability for business-related debts or other factors.
Pro #2: Flexibility
Consider these ways in which LLCs offer more flexibility than an S Corps:
- LLCs are allowed to have as many owners (members) as desired
- Members are not required to be US Citizens or residents
- Not required to have a board of directors
- Members make their own business decisions, while corporations have boards of directors and shareholders who are involved in those decisions
- Members may hire managers or appoint officers to make business decisions for the LLC
Disadvantage #1: Self-employment taxes
As we mentioned above, when comparing an S Corp vs an LLC, the self-employment taxes are a key disadvantage. Members of an LLC classified as a partnership are considered self-employed and must pay self-employment taxes (15.3%, which includes Social Security and Medicare) on their share of the LLC's income, regardless of whether the income is actually distributed to them.
Single-member LLCs (SMLLCs) classified as disregarded entities are treated like sole proprietorships for tax purposes. The owner reports all profits from the LLC on their personal tax return using Schedule C and pays self-employment taxes on the total net income from the business It cannot issue stock and cannot have shareholders, which may limit options for attracting members to the LLC.
Disadvantage #2: Entity Classification
The tax classification of an LLC depends on its structure and the decisions made by its members. The IRS offers flexibility in how an LLC is taxed. By default, multi-member LLCs are taxed as partnerships unless they elect C Corporate classification by filing Form 8832 or S Corporation classification by filing Form 8832 and then Form 2553 (or just filing Form 2553). Additionally, for a single-member LLC, the disregarded entity will be treated as part of the owner's tax return unless corporate treatment is elected by filing Form 8832 or Form 2553.
Download our FREE ebook Excel automation for accountants
With step-by-step tutorials and real world examples, learn valuable automation functions in Excel that save time, improve accuracy, and and enhance your skills!
S Corp vs LLC: A case study
S Corporation vs LLC comparison: Technology consulting firm case study
Understanding the tax and operational differences between business structures is crucial for entrepreneurs making entity-selection decisions. This report compares S Corporation vs LLC taxation for a technology consulting firm, with results presented in a clear, tabular format to highlight each option's financial implications and administrative considerations.
Business Profile: Technology Consulting Firm
Before examining the tax implications, let's establish the profile of our example business:
- Industry: Technology consulting services
- Ownership: Two equal co-owners (50% each), both actively working in the business
- Annual Revenue: $500,000
- Operating Expenses: $100,000
- Net Profit: $400,000 ($200,000 per owner)
This high-margin service business with substantial profits and active owner participation represents an ideal candidate for examining the structural differences between these popular business entities. The members agreed that the LLC would be taxed as a partnership; therefore, Form 8332 is unnecessary.
Financial comparison: S Corp vs LLC
Tax implications comparison table
| Tax considerations | S corporation | LLC (partnership taxation) |
| Income structure | $100,000 salary and $100,000 distribution per owner | $200,000 pass-through income per owner |
| FICA/SE tax rate 2025 | 7.65% for the employee and employer (6.2% for Social Security up to $176,100 plus 1.45% for Medicare with no wage base limit). An additional Medicare tax of 0.9% will apply to wages over certain threshold amounts for the employee only | 15.3% (12.4% for social security up to $176,100 plus 2.9% for Medicare with no wage base limit). An additional Medicare tax of 0.9% will apply to self-employment income over certain threshold amounts. |
| FICA/SE tax amount | $15,300 per owner ($7,650 employee and employer share) | $27,636 per owner |
| Annual FICA SE tax savings1 | Approximately $12,000 per owner | N/A |
| Section 199A deduction1 | Available | Available |
| Combined SE tax savings1 | Approximately $24,000 |
This table highlights the key tax advantage of S Corporation status: saving approximately $24,000 annually in Social Security and Medicare taxes by treating only part of the income as salary subject to employment taxes. Shareholders can pay themselves a reasonable salary while taking additional profits as distributions, which are not subject to Social Security or Medicare taxes, thereby reducing self-employment tax liability.
Administrative considerations: Comparison table
| Administrative consideration | S corporation | LLC (partnership taxation |
| Formation complexity | More complex articles of Incorporation and Form 2553 | Simplified articles of organization only |
| Formation costs | Typically higher ($100 to $300 state filing and $125 to $600 for S election) | Typically lower ($100 to $300 for state filing only) |
| Payroll requirements | Must establish payroll system and issue W-2s to owner-employees | No payroll requirements for members |
| Compensation scrutiny | "Reasonable salary" must withstand IRS review | No salary requirements; all income is treated equally |
| Record-keeping | Formal requirements: board meetings, minutes, resolutions | Fewer formal requirements |
| Annual filing | Form 1120-S Schedule K-1 for each shareholder | Form 1065 Schedule K-1 for each member (partnership) |
| Additional Compliance Costs | $1,000 to $3,000 annually (estimated) | $500 to $1,500 annually (estimated) |
This table highlights the increased administrative responsibilities associated with S Corporation status, which must be weighed against potential tax savings. Maintaining an S Corporation is more complex than running an LLC, as it requires you to run payroll and pay yourself a reasonable salary, among other obligations.
Business structure flexibility: Comparison table
| Flexibility consideration | S corporatoin | LLC |
| Ownership restrictions | Limited to 100 shareholders; no foreign owners | No restrictions on the number or type of owners |
| Ownership type | Only individuals, certain trusts, estates | Individuals, other LLCs, corporations, foreign entities |
| Capital structure | One class of stock only | Flexible capital structure, multiple classes of stock allowed |
| Loss pass-through | Limited by shareholder's basis | Generally, more flexible loss allocation |
| Asset distribution | Tax consequences for appreciated property | More flexibility for tax-free property distributions |
| Tax status elections | Limited to C or S corporations | Can elect any tax status (disregarded entity, partnership, C or S corp) |
This table demonstrates the LLC's advantage in terms of structural flexibility, which may be important for businesses planning significant growth, international expansion, or complex ownership arrangements in the future.
When S corporation status becomes advantageous for the 50% shareholder1: Comparison table
| Annual salary S Corp 50% shareholder | Annual profit for LLC - Form 1065 K-1 50% member | Estimate annual S Corp administrative costs | Social Security and Medicare tax with S Corp | Self-employment tax with LLC | Tax savings with S Corp | Net benefit of S Corp |
| $40,000 | $80,000 | $1,500 | $6,120 | $11,304 | $5,184 | $3,684 |
| $80,000 | $160,000 | $1,500 | $12,240 | $22,607 | $10,367 | $8,867 |
| $100,000 | $200,000 | $1,500 | $15,300 | $27,193 | $11,893 | $10,393 |
| $120,000 | $240,000 | $1,500 | $18,360 | $28,264 | $9,904 | $8,404 |
| $200,000 | $400,000 | $1,500 | $27,636 | $33,624 | $5,987 | $4,487 |
This analysis demonstrates that, despite the additional administrative costs, the S Corporation structure becomes increasingly beneficial as profits grow, particularly due to savings on self-employment taxes. However, for very low-profit businesses, the added compliance costs may outweigh the tax benefits, and the advantages diminish at higher income levels as the Social Security wage base is reached.
Conclusion: Optimal structure for the technology consulting firm
For this specific technology consulting firm, the S Corp structure offers compelling advantages:
- Substantial tax savings: Based on the example, the tax savings of $12,000 for the S Corp shareholder far outweigh the estimated $1,500 administrative costs, resulting in a net benefit of $10,500 ($21,000 combined for both shareholders).
- Balanced risk profile: The significant and recurring tax benefits justify the modest additional compliance burden.
- Long-term value: Over a 10-year timeline, the tax savings could exceed $200,000, representing a meaningful impact on the owners' financial outcomes.
S Corp vs LLC: Which should you choose?
The decision to choose an S Corporation vs an LLC hinges on the specific financial situation of your business. It can save or cost you money, so evaluating the actual numbers is essential. In the case study above, the economic data strongly favor electing an S Corporation for this profitable consulting business with active owner involvement.
However, if the business plans to undergo significant structural changes—such as international expansion, adding numerous owners, or complex capital arrangements—the flexibility of an LLC might be a more valuable option despite the higher self-employment tax burden it entails. As the businesses evolve, their needs may change, necessitating a transition between entity types. This analysis highlights the importance of quantifying the financial implications of each business structure based on your unique business profile rather than making decisions based solely on general principles.
Take the next step with Becker CPE
If you would like to learn more about choosing a business entity or other business-related tax topics, Becker's IRS-approved CE and CPE courses can help you build the knowledge and skills you need. Check out these courses to get started:
Unlock unlimited CPE with a Prime Subscription
Becker makes it easy to meet your CPE requirements, gain new skills, and stay aware of critical updates and changes in the industry!
With Prime, you can access over 1,700 courses for a full year and earn unlimited CPE credits.
Related Articles
Share
